Relative rarity (1-5, 1 is most common) 1) blue, green, red, yellow 2) aqua, copper, purple, light green 3) orange 4) olive, rose 5) magenta, pink Click here to check out the Register of magenta Sugar Caddies! Sugar Caddy interior colors: Sugar Caddy colors that came with both white and dark interiors include Blue, Green, Red, Aqua, Olive, Orange, and Purple. The Yellow, Light Green, Hot Pink, and Magenta have only been found with dark interior, and the copper brown models have only been found with white interior. Colors that are very hard to find with white interior include Red and Blue.